In Australia, the choice between buying a home or renting can feel overwhelming, especially with high property prices and competitive rental markets. While owning a home is often seen as essential for financial security, especially in retirement, renting offers flexibility and frees you from maintenance responsibilities.

So, which option is smarter financially? Here’s what Tash and Ana had to say.

Why the decision matters

The Australian retirement system largely assumes individuals will own a home by the time they retire.

Tash notes: “If you are only paying rent and you’re not investing, that can be a dangerous spot to be in. Because, in Australia, the retirement system is based off owning your own home at retirement . And if you’re not going to do that, you need to make sure you’re investing in another way to pay for your retirement.”

Ana reinforces this point: “If you’re not doing that, then you have no investments, no property, no equity.”

Without a home to live in rent-free or investments to fall back on, you could find yourself financially vulnerable in later years.

The Australian obsession with property

The culture around property ownership is deeply ingrained in Australia, perhaps even more so than in other parts of the world.

Ana says: “When I moved here, I was blown away with how obsessed Australians are with property. I mean, that’s the case everywhere in the world… but here there's such a focus on negative gearing and investment properties . Even the language around property is slightly different.”

Today, there's a growing movement of people who advocate renting over buying.

“I feel like there’s this other new crowd of people coming out saying: ‘No way I would ever ever buy. Renting is so much better. Renting is the winner financially,’” Tash observes.

The financial costs of buying a home

Buying a home is perceived by many to be a smart financial decision, but the upfront and ongoing costs can be high.

“I think often we just compare the mortgage versus the rent,” Tash points out. “But beyond the mortgage, there can be maintenance costs, there’s water rates and council rates, and there’s a land tax in some places as well.”

And don’t forget, as Ana points out, “stamp duty. The magical stamp duty.” This can often veer into the tens of thousands of dollars beyond the deposit.

Rent may seem like a straightforward monthly cost, but a mortgage brings additional financial commitments, especially with unexpected repairs and upkeep.

“With renting, you always know what you’re going to pay every month, says Ana. "The flip side with your mortgage is you have your insurance, your strata, and all these other things."

Potential pros of owning a home

Owning a home can offer stability and long-term security.

“Just having a place that’s home. I don’t have to worry about it… I have a place, my kids have a place, it’s ours,” says Ana.

For families, homeownership can provide a stable environment, avoiding the potential stress of moving when leases end or rents increase.

Homeownership can also allow people to build equity over time.

"There can be great benefits that come with owning your own home, like the tax benefits," Tash points out. "And you might have capital growth in the house you’re paying off as well, which is amazing.”

The flexibility of renting

Renting can offer a unique kind of flexibility, allowing people to live in desirable locations without the financial commitment of purchasing a home.

Ana says: “The biggest pro is you have flexibility, so you can live where you want. For me, it was really important to live close to the city. I was in an awesome neighbourhood that I knew I wasn’t able to afford [to buy in].”

Renters also benefit from fewer maintenance responsibilities. Ana shares her experience: “At one point our shower had a leak, so I got put into a hotel for a full week… and that was not something I had to pay for. The landlord had to pay for it.”

In contrast, homeowners are responsible for these types of repairs, which can be costly.

The importance of investing while renting

Renting is often cheaper in the short term, especially in major cities like Sydney and Melbourne, where property prices are high. However, renters should ideally be disciplined about investing their savings to build a financial foundation.

Tash notes: “When you rent, to actually make that a beneficial thing compared to buying, you do need to save or invest that extra money that you would have been spending otherwise.”

Ana points out: “If you’re renting, you might have a bit more disposable income. The interesting part is that if you take that additional money and invest it, you might potentially grow your wealth at a faster rate.”

The challenges of renting

While renting offers flexibility, it comes with its own set of challenges. Renters may face rent increases and difficulties finding housing, especially in competitive markets.

“The rental market is insane at the moment,” Tash adds. “It’s hard to have to stress about finding somewhere to live if your lease is ending – especially if you’re older and have kids.”

Additionally, renters don’t build equity in their housing. Tash emphasises that renters need to be proactive about investing:

“[You’re] not building any equity, so make sure you are investing in other places if you are renting.”

Weighing the pros and cons

The choice between buying and renting depends on personal circumstances, financial goals, and lifestyle preferences.

Potential pros of buying:

• Stability: Homeownership can offer a stable place to live, avoiding the potential upheaval of moving when leases end.
• Building equity: Homeowners have the potential for capital growth over time, and they don’t have to pay rent in retirement.
• Tax benefits: Homeowners may benefit from certain tax advantages, such as exemptions on capital gains tax for primary residences.

Cons of buying:

• High upfront and ongoing costs: Buying a home includes substantial costs like stamp duty, repairs, and maintenance.
• Less flexibility: Homeownership can make it harder to move or downsize quickly.

Potential pros of renting:

• Flexibility: Renters can move more easily and live in areas they may not be able to afford to buy in.
• Lower upfront costs: Renting typically requires a smaller financial commitment than buying.
• Less responsibility for maintenance: Landlords cover repairs and maintenance, sparing renters these costs.

Cons of renting:

• No equity building: Renters don’t build financial value in their housing.
• Potential for rent increases: Annual rent hikes and competitive markets can add financial strain.
• Less stability: Renters may have to move when leases end, which can be especially challenging for families.

Making the right decision for you

Ultimately, as you may have surmised by now, there’s no single “correct” answer to the buy vs. rent debate.

“In summary, there’s no one right answer. I think it all depends on you, your financial situation, where you’re at in your life as well,” says Tash. “Do you prefer the flexibility or do you prefer the stability? Can you afford to buy? Can you afford to rent and also invest? It all depends.”

Ana adds: “Your decision might change over time, and that’s totally okay too. So find out what works for you.”

As life circumstances and financial goals evolve, so too might your preference for owning or renting.

Whether you decide to buy or rent, the key is to be intentional about your financial choices. Renting can be a smart move if you’re investing the savings, while buying can provide long-term stability and equity. By carefully weighing the pros and cons, you can make the best financial choice for your future.

If this episode sparked something in you, give it a five-star rating, drop a review, or better yet, share it with a friend. And if you're just starting out, the first ten episodes will get the financial gears turning. Follow us at @getrichslowclub and catch our personal updates at @tashinvest or @anakresina.

Happy investing!